National Contingency Plan Product Schedule Toxicity and Effectiveness Summaries

For the products on the National Contingency Plan (NCP) Product Schedule, EPA provides a summary of effectiveness and toxicity for each of the product categories:

Appendix C to 40 CFR part 300 (PDF) (23 pp, 187K, About PDF) describes methods for required toxicity (Dispersants, Surface Washing Agents, Surface Collecting Agents, and Miscellaneous Oil Spill Control Agents) and effectiveness (Bioremediation Agents) tests.

Dispersants

Product

Toxicity (LC50 values in ppm) Effectiveness (%)
Product Only 1:10 Product to No. 2 Fuel Oil
Menidia
(96-hr)
Mysidopsis
(48-hr)
Menidia
(96-hr)
Mysidopsis
(48-hr)
Prudhoe Bay
Crude Oil
South Louisiana
Crude Oil
Average of
Crude Oils
ACCELL ® CLEAN DWD 5.66 2.07 8.05 1.32 58.70 96.03 77.37
BIODISPERS 13.46 78.90 5.95 2.66 51.00 63.00 57.00
COREXIT® EC9500A 25.20 32.33 2.61 3.40 45.30 54.70 50.00
COREXIT® EC9500B 29.13 10.00 4.46 2.13 57.00 50.90 53.90
COREXIT® EC9527A 14.57 24.14 4.49 6.60 37.40 63.40 50.40
DISPERSIT SPC 1000™ 3.50 16.60 7.90 8.20 40.00 100.00 73.00
FFT-SOLUTION® 5.34 2.72 5.14 2.75 49.97 48.87 49.42
FINASOL® OSR 52 11.66 9.37 5.40 2.37 32.50 71.60 52.10
JD-109 1.90 1.18 3.84 3.51 26.00 91.00 58.50
JD-2000™ 407.00 90.50 3.59 2.19 60.40 77.80 69.10
MARE CLEAN 200 1996.00 938.00 42.00 9.84 63.97 84.14 74.06
MARINE D-BLUE CLEAN™ 18.00 56.00 32.00 18.00 45.00 55.59 50.30
NEOS AB3000 91.10 33.00 57.00 25.00 19.70 89.80 54.80
NOKOMIS 3-AA 34.22 20.16 7.03 5.56 63.20 65.70 64.50
NOKOMIS 3-F4 29.80 32.20 100 58.40 62.20 64.90 63.55
SAF-RON GOLD 29.43 63.00 9.25 3.04 84.80 53.80 69.30
SEA BRAT #4 30.00 14.00 23.00 18.00 53.55 60.65 57.10
SEACARE ECOSPERSE 52 (see FINASOL® OSR 52) 11.66 3.77 5.40 2.37 32.50 71.60 52.10
SEACARE E.P.A. (see DISPERSIT SPC 1000™) 3.50 16.60 7.90 8.20 40.00 100.00 73.00
SF-GOLD DISPERSANT (see SAF-RON GOLD) 29.43 63.00 9.25 3.04 84.80 53.80 69.30
SUPERSPERSE™ WAO2500 37.10 17.40 3.70 2.53 77.84 87.56 82.70
ZI-400 31.76 20.96 8.35 1.77 50.10 89.80 69.90
ZI-400 OIL SPILL DISPERSANT (see ZI-400) 37.16 20.96 8.35 1.77 50.10 89.80 69.90

Top of Page

Surface Washing Agents

Product
(1:10 Product-to-No. 2 Fuel Oil ratio)

Toxicity
(LC50 values in ppm)
Menidia (96-hr) Mysidopsis (48-hr)
ACCELL ® CLEAN SWA 17.13 2.92
ALL PURPOSE CLEANER & REMEDIATOR (see GREEN BEAST™ OIL SPILL & ODOR REMEDIATOR) 7.15 2.24
AQUACLEAN 6.50 2.10
AT-TPH RELEASE 7.15 2.24
AWAN PRA OIL FIELD SOLUTION™ (see EPA OIL FIELD SOLUTION™) 2.94 1.12
BG-CLEAN™ 401 13.10 2.86
BIOGRASS EXTRA 2.54 2.24
BIOSOLVE® HYDROCARBON MITIGATION™ AGENT 7.40 1.30
CLEAN GREEN 4.73 2.24
CLEANGREEN® PLANET WASH 4.73 2.24
CLEAN SPLIT (see SPLIT DECISION SC) 0.25 2.06
CN-110 7.40 1.19
COREXIT® EC9580A 13.20 9.06
CORIBA 700 ER (see CORIBA 700 SR) 22.80 3.58
CORIBA 700 OS (see CORIBA 700 SR) 22.80 3.58
CORIBA 700 SR 22.80 3.58
CORIBA 713 ER (see CORIBA 713 SR) 9.55 4.04
CORIBA 713 OS (see CORIBA 713 SR) 9.55 4.04
CORIBA 713 SR 9.55 4.04
CYTOSOL 24.30 7.00
DE-SOLV-IT CLEAN AWAY APC SUPER CONCENTRATE 6.42 0.69
DE-SOLV-IT INDUSTRIAL CLEANER 9.40 1.68
DO ALL #18 9.38 0.57
DUO-SPLIT (see SPILT DECISION SC) 0.25 2.06
DYNAMIC GREEN™ 6.85 3.30
ECOVOOM-MARINE (see JEP-MARINE CLEAN) 3.58 2.32
E-SAFE© 8.77 14.20
ENVIROCLEAN 8.13 1.76
ENVIRONMENTAL 1 CRUDE OIL CLEANER 2.19 0.43
ENVIRONMENTAL 1 WASHING AGENT (see ENVIRONMENTAL 1 CRUDE OIL CLEANER) 2.19 0.43
EPA OIL FIELD SOLUTION™ 2.94 1.12
EO ALL PURPOSE SOAP-LAVENDER 3.14 2.37
ETHOS CLEAN 25.00 5.00
F-500 <10.00 32.00
FIREMAN'S BRAND SPILLCLEAN (see SPILLCLEAN) 3.30 1.30
G-CLEAN OSC-1809 6.05 2.51
GLOBAL ENVIRONMENTAL CLEANER™ (see EPA OIL FIELD SOLUTION™) 2.94 1.12
GOLD CREW SW 6.34 2.70
GREEN BEAST OIL SPILL & ODOR REMEDIATOR 7.15 2.24
GREEN BEAST WASHING AGENT (see GREEN BEAST OIL SPILL & ODOR REMEDIATOR) 7.15 2.24
GREEN TECHNOLOGIES SOLUTIONS-OIL RECOVERY (GTS-OR) 5.77 2.18
HYDRO-CLEAN™ (see EPA OIL FIELD SOLUTION™) 2.94 1.12
JEP-MARINE CLEAN 3.58 2.32
MARINE GREEN CLEAN™ 34.00 45.00
MARINE GREEN CLEAN PLUS™ 30.00 32.00
MICRO CLEAN (see NATURE'S WAY HS) 3.91 1.07
NALE-IT 3.82 1.84
NATURAMA G3 A-5 3.68 2.24
NATURE'S WAY HS 3.91 1.07
NATURE'S WAY PC (see NATURE'S WAY HS) 3.91 1.07
NOKOMIS 5-W 3.07 2.24
NONTOX™ SURFACE WASHING AGENT 3.29 2.19
OIL SPILL CLEANUP (see G-CLEAN OSC-1809) 6.05 2.51
OSR-10 16.00 4.77
PETRO-CLEAN 115.00 105.00
PETRO-GREEN ADP-7 10.95 1.12
PETROMAX PSC 3 1.99 1.00
PETROMAX SOIL CLEANING AND WASHING AGENT (see PETROMAX PSC 3) 1.99 1.00
PETROTECH 25 3.40 1.00
POWERCLEAN (see NATURE'S WAY HS) 3.91 1.07
PREMIER 99 8.20 2.50
PROCLEANS 4.78 11.68
SC-1000™ 4.72 2.13
SAFE KLEEN 2.60 6.50
SANDKLENE 950 4.48 2.24
SHEEN-MAGIC© 7.82 5.75
SIMPLE GREEN® 8.30 4.40
SOC 10 6.31 2.24
SPILLCLEAN 3.30 1.30
SPILLCLEAN ["Concentrate"] (see SPILLCLEAN) 3.30 1.30
SPLIT DECISION SC 0.25 2.06
SUPERALL #38 (see TOPSALL #30) 4.60 5.00
TOPSALL #30 4.60 5.00
TULXA 6.08 2.24
TXCHEM HE-100™ 7.07 2.11
VERU-SOLVE™ MARINE 200 HP 10.67 2.51

Top of Page

Surface Collecting Agents

Product
(1:10 Product-to-No. 2 Fuel Oil ratio)

Toxicity
(LC50 values in ppm)
Menidia (96-hr) Mysidopsis (48-hr)
SILTECH OP-40 9.70 3.27
THICKSLICK 6535 5.91 1.53

Top of Page

Bioremediation Agents

Product
(1:10 Product-to-No. 2 Fuel Oil ratio)

Toxicity*
(LC50 values in ppm)

Effectiveness (28 day)
Menidia (96-hr) Mysidopsis (48-hr) Alkanes
Reduction (%)
Aromatics
Reduction (%)
AGROREMED (see SPILLREMED (MARINE)®) 37.50 22.40 97.00 47.00
B&S INDUSTRIAL (see STEP ONE) NA NA 44.03 54.51
BET BIOPETRO NA NA 99.00 67.00
BILGE CLEAR (see S-200) 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40
BILGEREMED (see SPILLREMED (MARINE)®) 37.50 22.40 97.00 47.00
BIO-REGEN HYDROCARBON (see SOIL RX) NA NA 49.71 73.64
BIOREM-2000 OIL DIGESTER™ NA NA 99.80 71.00
BIOREM-2000 SC (see BIOREM-2000 OIL DIGESTER™) NA NA 99.80 71.00
BIOWORLD BIOREMEDIATION TREATMENT PRODUCTS 13.90 7.10 97.00 88.00
DRYLET™ MB BIOREMEDIATION NA NA 98.60 85.10
DUALZORB® 8.43 2.70 99.40 92.50
ERGOFIT MICRO MIX AQUA NA NA 99.10 82.20
HYDROREMED (see SPILLREMED (MARINE)®) 37.50 22.40 97.00 47.00
INIPOL EAP 22 (no longer manuf.) 125.00 35.00 93.87 23.25
JE1058BS 8.68 2.44 92.6 39.0
LAND AND SEA RESTORATION PRODUCT 001 (VELITE) NA NA 42.92 31.92
MICRO-BLAZE® NA NA 94.10 47.60
MICROSORB SC (see OPPENHEIMER FORMULA) NA NA 89.10 38.20
MUNOX SR® NA NA 94.9 75.5
OILCLEAN w/ACTIVATOR (see PRO-ACT) NA NA 99.86 94.15
OIL GONE EASY (see S-200) 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40
OIL SPILL EATER II (OSE II) NA NA 89.80 89.60
OPPENHEIMER FORMULA NA NA 89.10 38.20
PRISTINE SEA II (no longer manuf.) NA NA NA NA
PRO-ACT NA NA 99.86 94.15
REMEDIADE™ NA NA 99.0 99.4
S-200 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40
S-200C (see S-200) 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40
S-200 OIL CLEAN (see S-200) 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40
S-200 OIL GONE (see S-200) 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40
SHAMANTRA BIO (see SHAMANTRA GREEN) NA NA 99.7 95.3
SHAMANTRA GREEN NA NA 99.7 95.3
SHEENCLEAN (see S-200) 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40
SOIL RX NA NA 49.71 73.64
SP 7010 (see REMEDIADE™) NA NA 99.0 99.4
SPILLREMED (INDUSTRIAL (see SPILLREMED (MARINE)®) 37.50 22.40 97.00 47.00
SPILLREMED (MARINE)® 37.50 22.40 97.00 47.00
STEP ONE NA NA 44.03 54.51
SUMP SAFE BIO-RECLAIM NA NA 47.40 49.00
SYSTEM E.T. 20 NA NA 99.10 77.00
TRAILZORB (see DUALZORB®) 8.43 2.70 99.40 92.50
VAPORREMED (see SPILLREMED (MARINE)®) 37.50 22.40 97.00 47.00
*VB591™, VB997™, BIONUTRIX® NA NA 96.80 73.10
WASTE AWAY® 12.54 2.11 99.20 60.70
WHITZORB (see DUALZORB®) 8.43 2.70 99.40 92.50
WMI-2000 NA NA 60.30 33.30
Z-11 (SEE S-200) 25.33 17.67 98.00 10.40

*Toxicity testing is not required for Bioremediation Agents; data provided if submitted by vendor.

Top of Page

Miscellaneous Oil Spill Control Agents

Table 1: Miscellaneous Oil Spill Control Agents

Product
(1:10 Product-to-No. 2 Fuel Oil ratio)

Toxicity
(LC50 values in ppm)

Effectiveness (%)
Menidia (96-hr) Mysidopsis (48-hr)
ELASTOL 8.20 3.70 NA
LIQUID ELASTOL (see ELASTOL) 8.20 3.70 NA
MARI-ZYME (see ZYME-FLOW) 8.70 1.60 NA
OPFLEX® THE GREEN STUFF 5.49 1.67 NA
PES-51 435.00 14.50 NA
PX 700™ 5.65 2.77 NA
SEPARATE (see ELASTOL) 8.20 3.70 NA
UNITED 658 PETRO-ZYME (see ZYME-FLOW) 8.70 1.60 NA
ZYME-FLOW 8.70 1.60 NA
ZYME-TREAT (see ZYME-FLOW) 8.70 1.60 NA
Table 2: Solidifiers

Product
(1:10 Product-to-No. 2 Fuel Oil ratio)

Toxicity
(LC50 values in ppm)

Effectiveness (%)
Menidia (96-hr) Mysidopsis (48-hr)
ALSOCUP 14.00 10.00 NA
AQUA N-CAP™ POLYMER 22.50 2.13 NA
CIAGENT 5.93 1.73 NA
GELCO 200 3.15 3.51 NA
NORSOREX® APX 39.80 3.06 NA
OIL BOND® 3.80 9.60 NA
OIL SOLUTIONS POWDER (see AQUA N-CAP™ POLYMER) 22.50 2.13 NA
RAPIDGRAB 2000™ 4.07 2.60 NA
SPILL GREEN LS (see AQUA N-CAP™ POLYMER) 22.50 2.13 NA
WASTE-SET 3200® 552.00 58.00 NA
WASTE-SET 3400® 442.00 36.00 NA

Top of Page