Enforcement

Confetti String Clean Air Orders Settlement

(Washington, D.C. - Sept. 05, 2006) EPA has ordered five national retail chains to pull from their shelves cans of illegally imported confetti string products that contain banned hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs). These substances deplete the earth's protective stratospheric ozone layer and increase the risk of skin cancer. Millions of cans of these novelty items, all imported from China or Taiwan and known by various names such as Zany String, Crazy String, and Party Streamer, have been sold illegally in the United States.

EPA banned HCFC propellants in spray cans more than a decade ago. Now, we are seeing imports of these products from overseas manufacturers that claim their products comply with American laws," said Granta Y. Nakayama, EPA's assistant administrator for Enforcement and Compliance Assurance. "We are pleased that these retail companies signed these compliance orders with EPA to ensure that these products will not be available to consumers and the ozone-depleting substances they contained will never make it into our environment."

What sorts of products are involved?

The products are known by various names, such as Zany String, Crazy String, and Party Streamer.

Top of page


What volume of illegal products have been sold?

Million of cans of these novelty items have been sold in the United States and over 2.7 million cans will be incinerated under these compliance orders. Approximately 1.5 million additional cans were sold to the public before the illegal sales were stopped. We assume that most of these cans have vented their ozone depleting propellants to the atmosphere.

Top of page


When were these products banned?

EPA banned the use of ozone eating propellants in spray cans decades ago when the Montreal Protocol was adopted. Then, in the 1990 Amendments to the Clean Air Act, specific statutory authority was added to Title VI prohibiting their use. Implementing regulations were promulgated in 1993.

Top of page


Where are the illegal products coming from?

We are seeing imports of these products from overseas manufacturers that claim their products comply with all American laws, mostly from China and Taiwan. None of the United States or European manufacturers of confetti string have been found to have illegal propellants.

Top of page


How did EPA identify these violations?

EPA inspectors purchased cans of string confetti products at large chain retail stores throughout the country. EPA chemists analyzed the samples at the EPA Environmental Science Center, Ft. Meade, Maryland. EPA's investigation found that many stores sold illegal product, all of which was imported from China and Taiwan. The companies found to have illegal product on their shelves are Dollar Tree, American Greetings, Inc., Dollar General, Target, and Too, Inc. which owns Limited Too.

Top of page


What is being done to address the violations?

These companies have agreed to cooperate with EPA's investigation, to stop sales by taking the banned product off their shelves, and to ship the banned products to an incinerator company that will ensure that the ozone-depleting substances are destroyed.

Top of page


What regulations are at issue?

The sale or distribution of any such confetti string product containing similar ozone-deleting substances is banned by EPA's regulation, found at 40 Code of Federal Regulations, Part 82.

Top of page


What environmental harm comes from these products?

These ozone-depleting substances, used as propellants, attack the stratospheric ozone layer which protects human and animal life from skin cancers, cataracts and other ailments.

Top of page


What else are these companies doing to solve the problem?

The companies have also agreed to audit their operations and adopt new policies to ensure that these problems do not arise again.

Top of page


What else is EPA doing to prevent these problems?

EPA is in contact with Chinese environmental officials in hopes of preventing the export of illegal products to the United States.

Top of page


Contact

For additional information, contact:

Charlie Garlow
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (2242A)
1200 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, DC 20460-0001
(202) 564-1088
garlow.charlie@epa.gov

Top of page